Your bank has pre-approved you, a broker says they can beat the bank's terms and neither charges you to talk. On 3 November 2026, the Reserve Bank of Australia raised the cash rate to 4.85%, its fifth rise of the year. Choosing between your bank and the broker comes down to who is recommending your loan, what the law requires of them and how they show the loan suits you.
More than 80% of home loans are now arranged through mortgage brokers, according to the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). For its October 2026 review, ASIC examined eight large broker groups covering about two-thirds of broker representatives, with data running from 1 April 2023 to 31 March 2025. Seven of the eight reported that their brokers did not recommend the cheapest loan option in more than 20% of cases.
These findings do not make a broker the wrong choice, or your bank the safe one. They mean putting the same questions to any mortgage broker in Brisbane you sit down with, us included, and several of them to your bank's lending specialist.
Legal Duties of Brokers and Banks
By law, a broker must put you first, while a bank selling its own loans owes you no such duty but must still lend responsibly. Rates and fees show how brokers and banks compare on price, but these obligations decide whose interests shape the advice:
Broker Duties
Mortgage brokers have had to meet the best interests duty in the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (National Credit Act) since 1 January 2021. Where a broker's interests conflict with yours, including over commission, yours take priority.
ASIC's Regulatory Guide 273 treats a failure to consider cost, and to look into cheaper options, as a possible sign the duty has not been met. A broker should be able to show how the alternatives compared and why the loan suits your deposit, income and plans, not just that the lender approved it.
Bank Duties
A bank must make reasonable inquiries about your needs, verify your finances and assess whether the loan would be unsuitable for you, under the National Credit Act's responsible lending obligations.
Even a loan that passes this test can cost more than others you qualify for. The bank only compares its own products, so it has no obligation to point you to a cheaper loan elsewhere.
A useful question for your own bank is whether its offer matches the rate it gives new borrowers for the same loan. Lenders can offer new customers discounts that existing borrowers do not automatically receive, so a written figure is easier to set against what a broker brings back.
Written Assessments
Both a broker and a bank must give you a free copy of their assessment of your loan if you ask. A broker's version is called a preliminary assessment, and under the National Credit Act it must be provided within seven business days if you ask within two years of their help. If you ask later, up to seven years, the deadline is 21 business days.
These copies are most useful before you sign. The broker's assessment records what they understood about your requirements and objectives, so it shows quickly whether they heard you. A mismatch is worth raising while it can still be fixed, such as a loan term you never discussed or a feature you said you would not use.
Comparing the recommended loan amount with your own estimate from a mortgage calculator can also show whether the recommendation sits at the top of your likely borrowing range.
Questions to Ask a Mortgage Broker
Well-chosen questions make the recommendation prove itself. Checks on experience and reviews are part of choosing a mortgage broker, so these questions focus on the advice:
1. Cheapest Suitable Loan
The first question is which loan would have cost you least while still fitting your needs, and how far it sits from the recommendation in dollars. A broker who has done the comparison should be able to answer without going away to check.
The gap matters most over the years you expect to keep the loan, since you may refinance or sell well before the end of a 30-year term. A sound answer names the cheaper loan and explains why it was or was not chosen. Hesitation, or a reply that only talks about the recommended lender, is a reason to ask again.
2. Extra Cost
A loan that costs more than the cheapest option can still suit you, and ASIC accepts that some loan features may justify the extra cost. The regulator expects evidence, though, and the bigger the cost difference, the stronger it needs to be. The question is what the extra money buys and whether you are likely to use those features.
In a hypothetical example, two $600,000 loans run over 30 years, principal and interest. Loan B charges about 6.3% and adds a $12,000 premium for lenders mortgage insurance (LMI), the cover that protects the lender and usually applies when you borrow more than 80% of the property's value. Loan A charges 0.20% more but waives LMI.
Loan A's higher rate costs roughly $5,800 in extra interest over the first five years. That is under half the $12,000 premium, before counting the interest charged on it. These are example figures only, not a quote, and LMI premiums vary by lender, insurer and deposit size.
Over a longer period, Loan A's advantage narrows, so which loan costs less depends on how long you expect to hold it. Comparing low deposit home loans usually involves this kind of trade-off, and a broker should be able to set it out in writing.
3. Broker Commission
The broker should be able to say how much they would earn on each loan they compared. Lenders often pay brokers a commission on the loans they arrange, and ASIC's Moneysmart website notes that some brokers are paid more for certain loans than for others.
A credit proposal disclosure document setting out the fees and commissions involved must be given to you when a broker provides credit assistance, such as suggesting a loan or helping you apply. Where the recommended loan pays the broker more than the cheaper option, the choice deserves an explanation with both figures in front of you.
4. Lender Panel
The lenders a broker is accredited to use are known as their panel. ASIC does not necessarily require a broker to recommend loans from outside that panel, although the regulator expects it to be broad enough for the broker to act in your interests. Some lenders do not accept broker applications at all, so it is worth knowing which lenders the broker cannot access and whether any of them might suit your situation.
A broker who names the gaps and explains why they are unlikely to matter for you gives you more to work with than one who only quotes the size of their panel. Where a lender outside the broker's reach could suit, a direct quote from that lender, or from your own bank, is still worth having for comparison.
5. Government Deposit Scheme
Only participating lenders can offer the Australian Government 5% Deposit Scheme, so a broker should be able to tell you which lenders on their panel take part. Subject to eligibility and the lender's approval, the scheme lets first home buyers purchase with a 5% deposit and no LMI.
Housing Australia lists the property price cap at $1,000,000 for Brisbane, the Gold Coast and the Sunshine Coast. For the rest of Queensland, it is $700,000. Both the price and the lender's valuation need to sit at or under that limit. Caps can change, so the figure for the exact postcode is worth confirming before you make an offer.
6. LMI Waiver
An LMI waiver for professionals such as doctors, registered nurses or lawyers is a lender policy, so availability depends on the lender and your role. Published waivers typically allow borrowing of around 90% of the property value without LMI. A few lenders go to 95% for selected professions, depending on your registration, income and the loan.
Your own bank may offer the scheme, a waiver, both or neither. For a first purchase, a first home buyer mortgage broker should be able to show which of these options you may qualify for before you start making offers.
7. Property Type
Lender policy on property varies, so a broker may know which lenders on their panel have recently accepted a property like the one you are buying. Small inner-city units, homes on flood-mapped streets and older Queenslanders with later additions are among the Brisbane properties that may draw different answers from different lenders.
Your bank can only speak to its own policy. A broker comparing several lenders should be able to say which ones are likely to accept the property, and which may ask for more before they will.
8. Complaints Process
Standard complaints must generally receive a response within 30 calendar days under ASIC's Regulatory Guide 271, so it helps to know who handles them at the broker and how to lodge one. ASIC's review found that disputes over the broker duty took longer to resolve than other complaints. Some were missed, withdrawn without full investigation or delayed.
Brokers who can name the person responsible and explain the process clearly are showing the follow-through you want. Unresolved complaints can go to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), which offers free, independent dispute resolution. The broker's credit guide, the disclosure document they give you early on, should include AFCA's contact details.
Choosing Your Loan With Proof
A practical next step may be to have the broker answer these questions in writing and your bank put its offer on paper. Each should price the recommended loan and the cheapest suitable alternative it can offer over the years you expect to keep the loan.
If you are weighing up your bank's offer against a broker's recommendation, Hunter Galloway can talk you through the options that suit your circumstances.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
This article provides general information only. It does not consider your objectives, financial situation or needs. Scheme settings, rates and thresholds are current at the time of writing and may change. A qualified professional can help you consider whether this information suits your situation before you act.

